The White Sox couldn't hit CTRL-Z on their disastrous midseason trade for Luis Castillo, but they did what they could do undo the financial damage.
In a deal first reported by Jeff Passan and confirmed by everybody else, the White Sox have traded Castillo and his $22.75 million salary to the Colorado Rockies along with Davis Martin, receiving left-handed starter Sean Sullivan and 17-year-old catching prospect Douglas Veliz in return.
The transaction eliminates the considerable awkwardness of carrying Castillo, who came to the White Sox with a 5.06 ERA, only to give up 30 runs over 31 innings during his stay on the South Side. And considering the White Sox traded a pitcher on the 26-man roster (Seranthony Domínguez) and a catching prospect (Boston Smith) to Seattle to acquire Castillo back in July, it's almost like the first trade never happened.
It just comes down to how you value Martin, who was a Cy Young candidate over the first 2½ months of the season, and left out of postseason action by the end of it.
| Starts | IP | H | HR | BB | K | W-L | ERA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First 13 | 78.1 | 69 | 3 | 17 | 79 | 9-2 | 2.41 |
| Last 16 | 67.2 | 77 | 11 | 29 | 43 | 0-6 | 5.72 |
| Total | 146 | 146 | 14 | 46 | 122 | 9-8 | 3.95 |
If his problems really did stem from a calf issue and there's nothing else preventing him from rediscovering his mid-rotation form, then dumping Castillo's salary cost the White Sox the sort of pitching depth they sorely need. However, if sustained above-averageness proves fleeting for Martin, then he might have only added to the uncertainty of figuring out the White Sox's best five starters.
Until Martin is able to validate everybody's best guesses, the White Sox have pared down their options, and made it a lot easier to envision both how the they could both could sell another starting pitcher on an unfettered opportunity, and how they can afford him. At present, the rotation looks like Sean Burke, Dustin May, Grant Taylor, Anthony Kay and a host of less proven options for the fifth starter job. An ideal rotation would have one more proven starter who can push Kay or Taylor to the fifth spot, and leave the younger arms on the outside, at least for Opening Day.
Coming over from Colorado are Sullivan and Veliz. Sullivan, 24, was a second-round pick of the Rockies out of Wake Forest in 2023. He earned a midseason look in June, but didn't fare particularly well, posting an 8.87 ERA over five starts, even with a head start of three scoreless innings in his debut. However, he left his inaugural start early with an illness, and then went to the injured list after his fifth start due to a left shoulder impingement.
He only made three brief appearances in September the rest of the season, but the Rockies sent him to the Arizona Fall League afterward, where he laid waste to the competition in the showcase, recording 20 strikeouts against a single, solitary walk over 14⅔ innings.
Sullivan told MLB.com that he chalked up his rocky MLB performance to insufficient preparation, and that he'll be better equipped the second time around.
But in the Majors, Sullivan struggled with a key issue that’s difficult to prepare for in the Minors -- pitching on four days’ rest consistently, with Major League intensity. In the Minors with Monday being a regular day off, the only time a pitcher goes on four days’ rest is when his turns fall Tuesday and Saturday. Sullivan said discussions with the strength and conditioning program, as well as with the club’s dietician, should help him go from “skinny but strong to filled-out.”
When Sullivan takes the mound with the White Sox organization, the first place to look will be his fastball velocity. He sat 91-92 mph in college, and when pared with 7.7 feet of extension from a 6-foot-4-inch frame, he was more than enough. Last year, that fastball was down to 88 mph, and missing bats proved difficult at both Triple-A Albuquerque and Colorado. Perhaps he regains his missing ticks, but he also wouldn't be the first Wake Forest pitching prospect who peaked in college.
Veliz, who doesn't turn 18 until February, hit .300/.521/.400 over his first 117 professional plate appearances in the Dominican Summer League. He signed out of Venezuela for $50,000 and didn't appear in any international reports from Baseball America, but the trade inspired BA's first write-up a few minutes ago:
Like any 17-year-old catcher, Veliz has a long way to go developmentally. Early in the season, he was setting up with the conventional crouch, but he did start to use a one-knee setup with an increased focus on framing as the season wore on.
He plays with energy and enthusiasm, and he showed a solid approach at the plate. He hit .300/.521/.450 in 29 games in the Dominican Summer League. That absurd on-base percentage is a function of the wildness of many DSL pitchers, but Veliz does know the strike zone, posting well above-average chase rates and very low in-zone miss rates when he swings. He had a sub-85 mph average exit velocity in 2026, but that should improve as he gets older and stronger.
It's an uphill climb for both prospects, so it's fair to call it a salary dump until proven otherwise. It's just a little more nuanced than a standard salary dump because you also have to rope in the first trade, and that adds some complexity.
The first deal was about dumping Domínguez's $12 million obligation with the hopes that Castillo would be more useful, even if his contract was just as submerged. In purely financial terms, using Domínguez to take on Castillo's contract was a double-or-nothing bet that went wrong, and this trade with Colorado was another double-or-nothing bet that ultimately cleared the debt.
This chain just also cost the Sox the two best players involved in both trades -- first Smith, and now Martin. Smith hit 31 homers while batting .274/.424/.566 for four different teams last year, and Martin has a track record of back-end adequacy, and he still hasn't even reached arbitration eligibility.
There's a decent chance the Sox sold high-ish on both. Perhaps Smith's contact issues catch up to him in Triple-A, and he's more of an all-or-nothing power bat without a position, while Coors Field ends up being an impossible setting for Martin's game to thrive. But if either hit on their potential, then that's a hefty price to pay for shedding a salary that was going to be off the books after 2027. The only way for the Sox to soften it is to reallocate that money first earmarked for Domínguez and then Castillo for a player who actually helps.






