Skip to Content
White Sox News

White Sox signing Dustin May to three-year deal

10:41 AM CST on November 17, 2026

New White Sox pitcher Dustin May

Dustin May

|Larry Radloff/Icon Sportswire

The White Sox made no secret about their desire for starting pitching, and so it makes sense that their first move of the offseason addresses that need.

Dustin May is in the fold on a three-year, $52.5 million contract, with Robert Murray breaking the signing, and Jon Heyman the amount.

2026 was May's healthiest season yet, as he set career highs in games/starts (31) and innings (145⅔) with the Cardinals and Brewers. He signed with St. Louis last winter for one year and $12.5 million before being sent to Milwaukee at the deadline. He fared worse for the better team ...

TeamGIPHHRBBKERA
STL211091057351064.38
MIL1036.237715385.65
Total31145.214214501444.70

... but he still had a World Series ring to show for it, and now he has his first big payday as well.

It's taken long than he expected. He broke into the big leagues with the Dodgers at 21 in 2019, and seemed to plant his flag with a strong showing in the pandemic year, but a series of health issues conspired against an encore. He lost most of the 2021 and 2022 seasons to to Tommy John surgery, needed a revision surgery on his elbow in 2023, and then suffered an esophageal tear as he was about to start a rehab process in 2024, and the combination of those last two events caused him to miss the whole season.

It's been comparatively smooth sailing since, as he's thrown 56 games and 278 innings for four different teams over the last two years, but the 4.82 ERA and 4.22 FIP reflects his tendency to run hot and cold, and leave the idea that there's more in there.

The White Sox are taking that bet. The three-year, $52.5 million comes in slightly above FanGraphs' median crowdsourced estimate (three years, $48 million). Despite the multiple elbow surgeries, he still manages to average 97 mph on his fastball. The secondaries are a work in progress, as he's altered his pitch usage considerably. He used to lead the way with a lower-slot sinker, but the arm angle has come up, and now he uses a four-seamer and cutter slightly more often, with the sweeper being his primary breaking ball.

The question is whether May is leading the White Sox's free agent charge, or whether he's merely a piece in it. As a secondary starter, he undeniably adds to the depth, but you'd like the main attraction to have more credibility in starting a postseason game. Considering May is the third-largest commitment the White Sox have made to a pitcher in terms of total dollars and second-largest in terms of average annual value -- Dallas Keuchel's three-year, $55.5 million contract in 2019 leads both -- it's hard to tell right now.