Skip to Content
Features

P.O. Sox: Shuffling White Sox pitchers, CBA talks, and who can talk during a lockout

7:00 AM CST on November 17, 2026

The White Sox will have to make roster news later today, as the deadline to add players to the 40-man roster ahead of the Rule 5 draft arrives at 5 p.m.

Last year, this deadline spurred a ton of activity, with the White Sox trading for Chris Murphy, Everson Pereira and Tanner Murray alongside the additions of Tanner McDougal and Duncan Davitt to the 40-man. Given that the White Sox have less playing time for auditions this time around, I wouldn't expect them to be as aggressive in using their roster spots for other teams' fringe players, but we'll see.

The 40-man roster is at 39, so the White Sox will need to make at least one other move if they want to protect William Bergolla Jr. and Jaden Woods.

While we wait for that, take a gander at the latest P.O. Sox mailbag, featuring questions from those who support Sox Machine at the 10 WAR tiers and higher.

While a lot of hopes for next year ride on improvements from guys like Colson Montgomery, Noah Schultz, and Hagen Smith, what about less heralded young players like Tristan Peters, Chase Meidroth, and Sam Antonacci? Do you think they can repeat or even build on their 2026 performances, or should we expect some regression?

Trooper Galactus

I'm not certain how much more building they can do, so I think the move is to guard against regression versus putting greater expectations on their shoulders, and I think you can see the White Sox attempting to do the same. They brought in Brenton Doyle to give Peters a solid platoon partner who was a 4 WAR center fielder in his own right in 2024. If Peters happens to have the same kind of struggles providing an encore for his own 4 WAR season, at least they can lean upon each other.

As for Antonacci and Meidroth, if the White Sox are able to add an outfielder that takes "primary left fielder" off Antonacci's plate, then they have each other as platoon partners at second base if the bottom comes out from under both of their games. Meidroth feels the most stable of the bunch now that he's added a little bit of pop, but I'm most looking forward to seeing how Antonacci evolves. He provided a lot of value, it was a very specific kind of value (OBP from the leadoff spot) around significant detriments (minus defense, no homers over his last 55 games). If the team needs less of what he gave them and more of what he couldn't, how does that change his status? Or can he shore up one of his weaknesses, and he'll remain a fixture?

Am I correct in that it seems Hagen Smith is not being seriously considered for the rotation next year. Why is that? Why not construct a rotation from Burke, Martin, H. Smith, Kay and a free agent addition?

John S.

Smith is fighting a two-front war, in that he's missed a month or more to injury in both of his full pro seasons, and he has trouble maintaining strike-throwing form over the course of multiple innings when he is on the mound. Pitching out of the bullpen theoretically alleviates both of those concerns, as it's a little less rigorous, and also has minimal downstream effects if an inning isn't nearly as efficient as it should've been. If he throws 45 pitches over two innings, then he's not available the next two days. If he throws 45 pitches over two innings, you might have to get relievers warmed by the fourth inning, and it's a bullpen game before you knew it.

I think the hope is that he pitches a full, healthy season in 2027 and gets a strong enough handle on his mechanics that one walk doesn't turn into three walks, and then everybody can revisit this conversation like they did with Grant Taylor. Speaking of which...

With Grant Taylor moving into the rotation for 2027, it got me thinking about leverage. On one hand, I understand why Grant Taylor might want to become a starter. He and his agent understand what top-line starters get paid, so why not ask for a spot in the rotation (or express strong interest) and try to maximize his negotiating leverage for a future contract, right? Meanwhile, the Sox will now need to reconfigure how they handle in-game leverage scenarios because their eraser is shifting to a much less adaptive role. 

I've seen folks do simple arithmetic on high-leverage innings to calculate the new deficit, but it got me thinking about synthesizing those two leverage concepts above. Do teams with stronger starting pitching better "contain" high-leverage moments to the back end of their bullpen, thus organizing pitching talent to engineer more straightforward paths to wins? Or am I thinking about the 2026 Sox in the wrong way and better starting pitching might actually expand the pool of high-leverage innings by keeping the Sox in more games for longer periods of time? Or does it all kinda come out in the wash, and is it really as simple as pitching your best pitchers the most possible innings being the most valuable thing a team can do in almost every case?

Any thoughts or ruminations of your own on all this?

Steve v.

Beyond financial implications, I think it's also the case that starters like owning a game, and having four days to prepare for ownership of that game. It's nice work if you can keep it.

The White Sox threw a wrinkle into leverage considerations during the ongoing conversation about openers last season by treating the first inning as a leverage inning because Walker McKinven said run expectancy was highest then. Under that definition, one way to think about is that a six-inning starter would be knocking down leverage innings until his offense knocks the game in a tension-reducing direction. That would theoretically reduce the amount of high-leverage innings, or at least make them easier to contain and allocate, at least if the offense is able to maintain above-averageness next season. If the offense struggles to scratch out four runs per game, then you get into the Cleveland Guardians' perpetual state of being, where a lockdown closer and lockdown setup men become vital to maintaining the delicate balance.

Having watched Rick Hahn run out of ideas and spend his last few seasons investing in the bullpen while letting everything else rot, I'm of the mindset that you should always prioritize the first six innings before investing heavily in the last three. There are always relievers available at the deadline.

How exactly would the Manfred plan for more equitable revenue sharing (specifically TV) between clubs work? Is it based on the upcoming new national contracts or also coercing the Dodgers, Yankees, Phillies, Red Sox et al to chip more into the pot for the “small market” teams (how would they be defined?). This seems like a key issue for the labor agreement but it is more between the owners than with the players. Manfred would certainly desire the NFL sharing model but baseball has a vastly different system. What is the MLB ultimate goal?

Cary C.

If the initial proposal has still held up under further revisions, then all local TV revenues would be fully shared. This used to be a contentious issue, but it isn't being framed that way right now. Perhaps it's too early in the negotiation process for wedge issues to make themselves known, but if the owners' emphasis is on franchise valuations and they believe a salary cap is what will allow them to explode into territories closer to NBA and NFL teams, then perhaps enough of them are willing to give up RSN money to make that happen. That private equity is getting a greater foothold into MLB ownership ranks might also make it more important to make the arrow go up faster, by any means necessary.

Is Brooks Baldwin expected to be ready headed into Spring Training?  If so, do you see a role for him to start the season on the major league roster?

Kevin H.

Scott Merkin provided a Baldwin update a couple of weeks ago, and it sounds like Baldwin experienced no setbacks and should be 100 percent ready to go when spring training rolls around. Based on the standards Luisangel Acuña set during his time holding down the last bench spot for an entire season, there's no reason why Baldwin couldn't do that job. But he does have two options remaining, so that could put him on the outside looking in depending on how the bench shakes out. The Sox may want to exercise that option just to see how he handles a return to everyday action.

Now that minor leaguers are a part of the MLBPA, how does the lockout affect players not on 40 man rosters? Is there a complete communication freeze with everyone?

Connor C.

While minor leaguers are part of the MLBPA, they negotiated a separate collective bargaining agreement that expires after the 2027 season, so players who are not part of 40-man rosters are not subject to lockout restrictions. Somebody like Caleb Bonemer can talk to coaches throughout the winter, and can report to spring training with the anticipation of playing games when the Charlotte Knights open their season on March 26. That's another reason for teams to err on the side of protecting fewer players from the Rule 5 draft this time around, especially if they have the sense that a lockout will result in the Rule 5 draft not being held at all.

Getz has seemed to say this is the offseason when withdrawals could occur from the SS prospect Savings account. Presuming that doesn't include Rock and Bonemer, which of Carlson, Lodise, Bergolla might go, and what sort of starting pitching might they bring back?

John G.

The tricky thing is that I don't think any of those players have tremendous trade value, or all of them would be selling low. Carlson and Bergolla both had leg issues that cost them big chunks of time, and Lodise struck out 141 times in High-A last year. Carlson seems like the only one with value, because although he went homerless over 60 games, his contact quality was decent before his leg infection took hold.

I see where many Sox fans are imploring that we prioritize free agent high quality starting pitchers. To be a contrarian, we see a continued high level of injuries to said starters due to their elevated velocity. We also know that said starters efficiency declines (linearly?) as they go through lineups a 2nd then 3rd time. Why not prioritize a staff of 7-9 +/- pitchers that can go 2-4 innings? This would increase your ability to maximize "lefty/righty” matchups, optimize performance via one to one and two times through lineups and would insulate you from the ever present risk of injury to a key starter that then substantially damages the team’s prospects? By spreading the payroll out you have more versatility and payroll flexibility, eh?

Ray U.

In theory, it makes perfect sense, and I think you're seeing postseason games starting to resemble this usage, because the October schedule has a lot of built-in rest. Over the course of a 162-game season, it's difficult to pull off, for a few different reasons.

The first is that, if you're essentially reserving two pitchers for usage in each of the next two days, it only takes consecutive tough games to start compromising the bullpen, especially if there isn't a starter who can handle six-plus innings by himself offering the possibility of restoring order.

It's also inventing a pitching role, with benefits and/or side effects that aren't known. Maybe it keeps pitchers healthier and fresher, or maybe doubling the number of starting pitchers' high-intensity outings over the course of a year leads to in-season drop-offs, but figuring it out will require buy-in across a team, and organization. Considering the Mariners couldn't get support for piggybacking one turn through the rotation, that's easier said than done. And then, if the injury rate isn't meaningfully different, then having such an entrenched system also makes it harder to acquire pitchers in-season, as they may or may not be compatible if their organization hasn't trained them for it.

The Astros were the closest to implementing something like this 10 or so years ago, but all it took were a couple of injuries up top to scrap the entire plan. There'd be a potentially immense payoff if it worked, but the risk is it being a dehumanizing mess with five whole months remaining, so I don't think it's worth it to try being an early adopter.

The next step in the evolution might be the development of 100-inning relievers with somewhat regimented use. We've seen the White Sox stumble into this sort of thing with Mike Vasil and Sean Newcomb the last two years, and they have a lot to offer a team with holes in the rotation, without requiring reworking pitchers who have the potential to throw 150-plus innings. It's just hard to know whether they incur any durability issues. Vasil undergoing Tommy John surgery the following spring doesn't lend a whole lot of confidence, even if that could've happened after a standard starter or relief season.