Eloy Jiménez showed it for a series

Oscar Mercado’s miracle catch in center field on Wednesday night shifted the perception of the White Sox-Indians series quite a bit. It saved the individual game, and it also saved the series, which would have been an even costlier blow to Cleveland’s playoff hopes. A split couldn’t keep them from falling behind Oakland in the hunt for the second wild card spot.

The catch also took away a double and multiple RBIs away from Eloy Jiménez, but Jiménez also absorbed friendly fire on the play. Jose Abreu’s baserunning boner meant that Jiménez felt a loss in two columns — he didn’t get an RBI, and he didn’t get a sacrifice fly that would have saved an out on his batting average. Abreu probably still feels terrible about it.

“My mistake,” Abreu said through a translator. “I got too excited because I never thought that Mercado had a chance to catch that ball, and that cost us a run. I feel bad. I apologized to Eloy, I apologized to Ricky. That was the right thing to do because when you make a mistake like that, you are costing one of your teammates some stats. I apologize to all of them.’’

In previous series, Mercado’s robbery could have been credited with stealing more than a couple of stats from Jiménez. It would’ve stalled a sense of progress, and everybody’s inability to catch a break on the few occasions something should’ve gone right.

But when Jiménez reaches his final form, one stolen extra-base hit shouldn’t make much of a difference in his week.

You wouldn’t have known he got unlucky in Cleveland from the numbers alone. Jiménez went 8-for-17 with two homers, three doubles and two HBPs over the four-game series, good for a line of .471/.526/1.000. He didn’t need an extra double to make him look adequate.

More than that, here was a series where you didn’t need positive results to know he looked better. He entered the game with a ground-ball rate of 50 percent, but 11 of his 13 batted balls at Progressive Field stayed in the air. On top of that, seven were hit over 100 miles per hour, including the one Mercado caught.

He’s been lacking this kind of spray chart:

And this is while Jiménez is still susceptible to being lured out off the plate. He swung at 13 pitches out of the zone, including seven sliders away and five fastballs high. One of the latter turned into the ball Mercado caught.

Jiménez can still be fooled, but Mike Clevenger said it’s not such a simple proposition anymore:

“I feel like he knows now how you’re gonna attack him and how you’re gonna beat him,” said Cleveland starter Mike Clevinger, who allowed two hits in seven innings, both to Jiménez. “He’s a good enough hitter now that that same slider — if you look at his second AB, his first AB, the slider hung up a little bit, got off the wall. Second AB, I threw the good slider I normally throw. He swung and missed, and I feel like he knew it was coming still. Third AB, I was kind of fatigued and didn’t want to go back to the heater, and I was like, ‘If I just get this slider away, I’m gonna get him again,’ and it hung up, and he’s good enough that if you hang it up in the zone, he’s gonna put it out.”

Jiménez showed what Clevenger meant on Thursday. Zach Plesac retired Jiménez the first two times, but both outs came on fastballs hit over 100 mph to the outfield. The third time up, Plesac tried to start him with a pair of sliders, but he hung the second one, and Jiménez found room along the left-field line for his eighth hit of the series, and his sixth on a slider.

This is what you want to see from Jiménez the rest of way, most obviously because it’s fun to watch. Most crucially, I wouldn’t want to see him overhaul his swing in the winter when nobody in the minors, inside or outside the organization, thought it posed a hazard in the majors.

The hope is that the first five months were all about the world’s most talented pitchers taking advantage of an enthusiastic hitter, and he needed that time to rewire his brain and sand down his most self-defeating impulses. He might still average a strikeout a game at this level at this age, especially when he faces a slew of tough righties like the ones Cleveland threw back-to-back-to-back, but I won’t care as long as the balls stay in the air. Be it launch angle or selectivity, if he can get one element of his game reliably in order, the other should eventually follow.

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
Jim Margalus
Jim Margalus

Writing about the White Sox for a 16th season, first here, then at South Side Sox, and now here again. Let’s talk curling.

Articles: 3913
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

That’s the Eloy I would expect to see next season. It was great to see him finally put the ball in the air consistently throughout the entire series. If he can do that next year, with his power, 40+ home runs is likely. With Moncada hitting 3rd and Eloy 4th, that is quite a dangerous duo. This week has shown what the young guys can do. If Rick can surround them with 3 or 4 good additions, next year could be fun.

karkovice squad

Speaking of encouraging developments, Fegan’s article on the Sox making use of data and tech to work on pitch design, tunneling, and mechanics was encouraging in a “finally!” kind of way. Cease’s discussion of his struggles to develop feel for his mechanics and changeup shows they’ve still got a gap in their knowledge of what they can see with data and what they can do to implement changes.

Yolmer's gatorade

There is nothing wrong with Eloy’s swing. His only problem is pitch recognition with the slider away and maybe the fastball up. If he can lay off those pitches, he will force pitchers to attack him in the zone leading to more hits and increase his walk rate as many pitchers will rather walk him than pitch to him. Even though his number are meh, it is amazing to see how much pitchers and teams respect Eloy’s talent by playing him really deep in the outfield and not pitching to him in the strike zone. His summer program should literally include somehow watching 1000 sliders away and fastballs up per day. Better pitch recognition is really all he needs.


I still think Manny Ramirez is his floor.


That is quite a floor

Trooper Galactus

Uh, waow.


Carl Skanberg’s portraits of Eloy and Yoan are majestic.


I’ve read a lot of people killing Abreu for his mistake, but how big a deal was it really? There were at 2 outs in the 9th afterwards, so it’s not like they had another opportunity to do a sac fly if everyone moved up. And they needed 2 runs to tie, so anything they might have done positive at that point would have required Abreu coming home before the guy on second anyway.

Yeah, Abreu could have made it 8-7 instead, but it’s not like that would have made the White Sox position stronger. It came down to whether Goins could get a hit or not anyway. A mistake, but one that seems meaningless.


It meant the runner on second couldn’t advance. If the tying run is at third, perhaps it takes a little away from the pitcher’s arsenal. Passed ball or wild pitch would have tied it. You’re right: it likely still comes down to Goins, but it reduces your odds on the margins. That’s where some games are won. And that kind of mistake in a different situation could have had a huge impact. Bottom line is Abreu screwed up twice on the bases, but it didn’t cost the Sox this particular game.