Skip to Content
2026-27 Offseason Plan Project

Same old Sox, running it back on the cheap

By The Department of Marginal Upgrades

9:25 PM CST on November 13, 2026

PREAMBLE

Let me be clear from the outset, this isn't the plan I hope the White Sox have, it's the one I fear we will actually get given Reinsdorf's longstanding unwillingness to pay for quality players.

After a surprising 2026 season and a trip to the postseason, the White Sox have an opportunity to build on their success. Unfortunately, with a potential lockout looming, Jerry Reinsdorf and Chris Getz have the perfect excuse to play their favorite offseason game: wait and see.

Forget blockbuster trades, expensive free agents, or anything that might suggest an ambitious offseason. My plan embraces the familiar White Sox approach: retain the young core, hope for continued development, and supplement the roster with inexpensive veterans, reclamation projects, and former top prospects whose best seasons may already be behind them.

There won’t be any headline-grabbing acquisitions here. Just a few familiar names, modest contracts, and enough theoretical upside for the front office to declare the offseason a success.

ARBITRATION-ELIGIBLE PLAYERS

  • Miguel Vargas: Tender
  • Brenton Doyle: Tender
  • Joey Bart: Non-tender
  • Huascar Brazobán: Tender
  • Jordan Leasure: Non-tender
  • Chris Murphy: Non-tender

VARGAS is a no-brainer since he's an important part of the young core. DOYLE provides elite defense in the OF. BRAZOBAN is affordable, experienced bullpen depth.

OTHER IMPENDING FREE AGENTS

  • Erick Fedde

ERICK FEDDE (2 years, $10M). A familiar, affordable veteran who provides valuable rotation depth and flexibility. $4M for 27 and $6M for 28.

FREE AGENTS

First off, the White Sox won't even entertain making offers to players who received Qualifying Offers (Arozarena, Bednar, Morejon, Rogers or Suzuki) because the Sox value their draft picks and international signing bonus money too much. They wouldn't even think about giving up a 2nd round pick and $500,000 in international money for any of these, no matter how much sense they make.

A few obligatory low-ball offers are made to the likes of Clay Holmes, Sonny Gray, Kevin Gausman, Foster Griffin, Keima Taira, Hiromi Itoh, and Kona Takahashi, etc. Predictably their offers fall well short of the competition. The Sox retreat to their familiar strategy of waiting for the market to settle after the lockout and picking through the leftovers.

Ultimately they sign:
GERMAN MARQUEZ, 1 year, $4M + $1.5M in incentives. A former quality starter whose best days are behind him but can be an innings eater.

JORDAN ROMANO, 1 year, $2.5M + $1M in incentives. A former All-Star closer who the Sox turn to to fill the Grant Taylor void in the bullpen. Like usual, the Sox think they can fix him.

DYLAN CARLSON, 1 year $1M + $500k in incentives. The 2027 Jared Kelenic! A former top prospect who has never fulfilled expectations, the Sox pick up Carlson because he's an inexpensive switch hitting outfielder.

FRANKIE MONTAS, Minor League contract + invite to Spring Training. A familiar face looking to make a comeback, the Reinsdorf dream!

Four unaspiring modest acquisitions with theoretical upside and moves that Jerry only grumbles about under his breath since it can end up costing him over $10M.

TRADES

SHANE SMITH sent to Arizona Diamondbacks for a high-A prospect who never pans out.

The Sox engage in discussions for Reid Detmers, Shea Langliers, Shane McClanahan, and even Steven Kwan but Getz/Reinsdorf balk when opposing teams demand top prospects in return.

Still smarting from their disastrous 2026 trade deadline, the team mostly stands pat. Instead of lessons learned from the deadline to make better trades for quality players, they opt to not make them.

SUMMARY

WAITING FOR ISHBIA

The White Sox have an opportunity to take a meaningful step forward, instead due to the lockout it's another winter of cautious spending, missed opportunity, and familiar excuses (hey look, we are spending $22.5M on a quality pitcher who we will fix!!!).

The Sox make token attempts at established talent, but as always refuse to compete financially. Trade discussions go nowhere because of the refusal to part with top prespects.

The resulting offseason is predictable; re-sign FEDDE, add reclamation projects MARQUEZ and ROMANO, and take a flyer on DYLAN CARLSON, a former top prospect.

Thus here's the lineup and salary amounts. Note that ROMO is kept as the backup as he will catch all of CASTILLO's starts. BALDWIN, MURRAY, BONEMER, SANDLIN, QUERO, etc are in AAA to start but will see time on the roster at some point during 2027.

Position Players: $47.6M
Pitching Staff: $53.05M
Total Commitment: $102.15M

STARTING LINEUP
C TEEL 800k
1B MURAKAMI 17.5M
2B MEIDROTH 800k
SS MONTGOMERY 800k
3B VARGAS 4M
LF ANTONACCI 800k
CF PETERS 800k
RF MONTGOMERY 800k
DH BENINTENDI 15.1M

BENCH:
C ROMO 800k
IF ACUNA 800k
OF DOYLE 3.6M
OF D. CARLSON 1M

PITCHERS:
STARTING ROTATION:
SP BURKE 800k
SP TAYLOR 800k
SP KAY 5M
SP CASTILLO 22.5M
SP MARQUEZ 4M

BULLPEN:
CL ROMANO 2.5M
SP/RP MARTIN 800k
RHP HICKS 8M
LHP HUDSON 800k
LHP H SMITH 800k
RHP BRAZOBAN 2M
LHP SCHWEITZER 800k
SP/RP FEDDE 4M

Position Players: $47.6M
Pitching Staff: $53.05M
Total Commitment: $102.15M