Age is the most inspiring number for White Sox lineup

The projections remain uninspiring, but a number of positions can beat them

The White Sox tied up some loose ends on their roster heading into the final day of Cactus League play. By reassigning Jeanmar Gomez and Bruce Rondon to minor-league camp, the White Sox are breaking camp with Gregory Infante, Juan Minaya and Aaron Bummer made the bullpen. Rick Renteria also officially named Carson Fulmer the fifth starter.

There are 27 players left in camp, and one of them is the injured Carlos Rodon, meaning that Kevan Smith and Omar Narvaez are the last ones battling for one spot. Smith hasn’t played since spraining his ankle, so it seems like Narvaez is the guy, but James Fegan provides a reason for such a delay:

The outcome of that position battle hasn’t been announced because Kevan Smith has not yet returned to action after spraining his left ankle, and could be a candidate to start the season on the disabled list rather than immediately optioned out of spring training in favor of Omar Narváez.

The White Sox roster settles just as FanGraphs’ annual position rankings spread to cover all the position players. The White Sox remain in the bottom third of the league on the whole, but the rebuild has taken hold long enough to finally put youth on their side. Let’s jog through the nine lineup spots and see how or whether they’ve progressed:


It seems like FanGraphs would do well to use a metric that incorporates framing to rank catchers. Welington Castillo should represents a year-over-year upgrade in that department, too, but the context across the league is a little less clear.

First base

Jose Abreu gained a half-win on his projection, which is no small feat for a player who is now on the other side of 30. Matt Davidson shaves two-tenths off the total, but more on him later. Fun fact: The seven teams ranked ahead of the White Sox are all in the National League.

Second base

What’s notable about Yoan Moncada’s projection (2.1 WAR) is that it involves slightly below-average fielding contributions. UZR was indifferent to his defense at second (-2.3 runs below average), but DRS loved him:

We’ve seen him make silly plays on the other side of second, so I wouldn’t be surprised if all metrics come around on his defense this year. And if 2 WAR is somehow conservative for his first full season, then hot diggity.

Third base

This is the difference between a reputable-if-limited veteran like Todd Frazier and a half-season of good baseball from Yolmer Sanchez. Given that Sanchez easily exceeded his projected 0.9 WAR last season, it seems like this is more of a floor than an average. Granted, Sanchez could be exposed by near-everyday play, but an expedition to his ceiling is a worthwhile use of the season.


Both Tim Anderson and Tyler Saladino underperformed their projections last year, hence the drop. Rian Watt notes Anderson’s personal trauma, but also that Anderson saw the highest percentage of sliders in the American League last year, and was one of just 18 hitters to see fastballs less than half the time, so there’s a specific baseball task to conquer.

Left field

This is a case study opposite of third base, in that going from a known veteran (Melky Cabrera) to a mystery man (Nicky Delmonico) results in a no loss in standing, and the mildest of bumps in projections. Cabrera’s unemployment has stumped some people because he’s an eminently watchable hitter, but his defense killed him.

Center field

And to think, last year’s White Sox projections were buoyed by two guys who didn’t play a game for them (Peter Bourjos, Charlie Tilson). Sure enough, they finished slightly worse than their projections (-0.2 WAR) because Adam Engel hit .166.

This year’s numbers look bad because Engel is getting 85 percent of the playing time. Credit Engel for using the spring to make himself interesting, which makes Jeff Sullivan’s write-up more than the “bless his heart” it could sound like:

Adam Engel was bad in front of thousands and thousands of people. Very bad. Conspicuously bad. He kept himself sharp in the field, and he vowed to come back a better player. I don’t know if he’s going to succeed, but he’s already gotten this far. The White Sox, politely, didn’t fill the job with somebody else.

No team is projected to be worse in center field than the White Sox. That’s because, last season, in center field, the White Sox were bad. And now, even now, they have hope. This is exactly what baseball is all about. I don’t care how trite that comes off.

Right field

Guys like Sanchez and Engel have to look no further than right field for somebody who took a blasting box to his projections. Avisail Garcia looked like a replacement-level outfielder the year before, and while a middle-of-the-pack projection won’t cause jaws to drop, he climbed out of a very deep hole.

Designated hitter

Add Matt Davidson to the list of players who are hoping to replicate Avisail Garcia’s journey to averagedom. His projections give FanGraphs’ chart an overbite:

Unlike Sullivan with Engel, Carson Cistulli isn’t in the mood to spin:

As an attempt to “problematize” language, however, the White Sox might have struck a rich vein here. For those who are unfamiliar, “problematizing” is something graduate students do when they’re not meditating bleakly on their career prospects. To problematize a concept or idea, one ponders a reality in which the opposite of that concept or idea is true. In the case of Davidson, for example, the White Sox appear to be asking what would happen if a designated hitter didn’t hit. A stirring thought! The 2018 season is likely to go some way towards producing the appropriate hard data.

I maintain that Davidson is worth watching in April, only because he cut his year-over-year spring strikeout rate from 38 percent to 27 percent. A Davidson who strikes out less than 30 percent of the time has something to contribute. That Davidson is merely theoretical at this point, and if that Davidson never materializes, then DH looks like a release valve for other young players who need at-bats for the other four or five months.

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
Jim Margalus
Jim Margalus

Writing about the White Sox for a 16th season, first here, then at South Side Sox, and now here again. Let’s talk curling.

Articles: 3791
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Has the Sox blog community ever been wronger about anybody (at least for a season) than about Avisail Garcia?


Shocking how nobody saw the historic level of luck coming.

Patrick Nolan

Tyler Flowers, maybe.

Trooper Galactus

The trick is to see if that .393 BABIP and his average-ish defense hold up for another season. I’m confident he’s returned to being a decent corner defender, but I’d expect a 40+ point drop in BABIP, which makes him a decidedly less interesting hitter, but still probably at least an average overall contributor.


I could envision a bit of a power increase to offset some of a BABIP drop


I would like to see these projections again at the end of the year to see what really stands out as ‘unexpected’. I like the DH plan. If we are spending our time and money, as fans, on a rebuild year, they need to learn all they can, as fast as they can. I know players need time for evaluation so this is the year.

Trooper Galactus

Good for Davidson for extending his MLB life with a good spring performance. If he’d scuffled at all I think he would have been off the roster for sure. That said, I still don’t think he’ll last through May, but I’d still love to see a version of him that strikes out less than 30% of the time.


As it stands this should be an above average defensive team. That’s something they haven’t had in a long while.

Trooper Galactus

Every ground ball pitcher should be ecstatic with this infield defense. Too bad Petricka lost his mojo in that regard.


Affix your crampons, Everyone. We’re taking an expedition to Yolmer’s ceiling!


Careful of the cobwebs!


This makes me think of the Mountain Climber game on the Price is Right.

Patrick Nolan

Very good


They’re underselling us at every position but catcher.

Abreu will be a finalist for MVP. Moncada will be an All-Star. Anderson will be league average or better. Sanchez will be in the vicinity of average. Jimenez will boost left field. Engel or someone will far outstrip the center field projection. I think it will be Engel with Gold Glove defense and tolerable hitting. Garcia will be above average, though it will involve more slugging and a lower average. Davidson will either improve or be replaced with Delmonico, thus pushing up DH. Catcher looks reasonable to me. I am bullish on this team.


Meet your 2018 division champs.


What about the pitching??!??


Fulmer 3rd in final Cy Young voting.

Right Size Wrong Shape

Brad Goldberg has 48 saves

“Big, Bad” Brad!


The fifth starter spot could be a problem for a bit if Fulmer can’t handle it. The other 4 spots are adequate (Gonzalez) to All-Star (Giolito). Rodon and Kopech will appear in June or July. By October Giolito, Rodon, and Kopech will be a formidable front 3.

The bullpen will be an asset. I’m not sure who they’ll all be. A couple spots may be bumped starters who thrive in the pen.

Don’t forget an improved defense will make the pitching look better, too. I am bullish.


I’d like a taste of whatever you’re having.

Trooper Galactus

If we get adequate out of Gonzalez and Shields, that’s half the battle right there.


I think Shields makes a playoff start this year. MiGo’s big if is staying healthy enough to make a meaningful contribution.


I voted this up just for the audacity of the optimism. Love it.


A couple of these should be easy overs. The Sox aren’t going to stay with Engel and Davidson for too long if they’re not producing at higher rates than last year. Depth is cool.

Lurker Laura

Carson Cistulli is trying very hard to be clever.


“Averagedom” is an interesting concept. Even moreseo when you do the grammatical gymnastics to get it to sound like “Armageddon”


I’ll show myself out.