White Sox 5, Tigers 3: No decisions for Dunning, Mize debuts

White Sox win

The twin major-league debuts of Dane Dunning and Casey Mize resulted in a draw over the first half of the game.

José Abreu and Edwin Encarnación generated the decision before the second half came to a close.

The veteran right-handed sluggers broke through a bullpen stalemate by dinging Tigers closer Gregory Soto with a pair of solo shots in the bottom of the eighth inning. Alex Colomé closed it out with a 1-2-3 ninth, and the White Sox have won four in a row, opposite an eight-game losing streak for Detroit.

Abreu only needed one pitch — and a compliant right field — to untie the game. He hoisted Soto’s elevated sinker high to the right side. On other nights, or in other parks, it might’ve fallen short of the warning track. This one drifted, and drifted, and drifted until it fell beyond Jorge Bonifacio’s outstretched glove and into the Kraft Kave for a 4-3 lead.

Two batters later, Encarnación needed no such assistance from the conditions. He ripped a high Soto sinker 107 mph into the bleachers in left center for an insurance run Colomé didn’t need.

Dunning comes away with a no-decision, but he could’ve been tagged with the loss, and the White Sox actually won. He’ll probably take it.

He came out firing before tiring. Jeimer Candelario ripped his first pitch over Nomar Mazara’s head for a double, but Dunning stranded him to start a streak of 11 consecutive Tigers retired, including three strikeouts in the third. He had excellent command of his fastball and multiple breaking-ball tilts until they started wobbling on him in the fourth. The Tigers might’ve weakened his knees with two line drives that Dunning caught right next to his head.

Dunning struck out Bonifacio with runners on the corners to end the fourth, and with his fastball starting to sail and the curveball starting to bounce, I would’ve been comfortable calling it a night for him there. Instead, he came out to start the fifth, and Rick Renteria left him in one to three batters too long. JaCoby Jones reached with an infield single to the hole on the left side, after which Greiner hit the second laser into Dunning’s glove. Dunning followed by walking Isaac Paredes on four pitches around a pickoff throw that got away from Abreu, but instead of Renteria making a mound visit, Don Cooper came out instead.

What Cooper said didn’t work. Candelario golfed an 0-1 slider high to right center, and it landed just over Adam Engel’s glove for a three-run homer and a 3-1 Detroit lead.

The White Sox got him off the hook, because their hitters got wise to Mize. Zack Collins broke an 0-for-14 slump to start the season with a double into the right-field corner, and he scored on Tim Anderson’s seeing-eye single two batters later to make it a one-run game. Anderson stole second and came home on Yoán Moncada’s game-tying RBI single that chased Mize from the game

That gave Mize’s night a similar shape to Dunning’s. Encarnación tagged him for the first of his two homers in the second inning, but the splitter showed up shortly after, and he spent the next few innings recording strikeouts and groundouts.

They ended up with nearly identical lines:

  • Dunning: 4.1 IP, 5 H, 3 R, 3 ER, 1 BB, 7 K, 1 HR, 73 pitches
  • Mize: 4.1 IP, 7 H, 3 R, 3 ER, 1 BB, 7 K, 1 HR, 73 pitches

Dunning had the edge in game score, 47-44. And also the final score.

The middle-relief segments of both bullpens restored order after the starters flagged. Matt Foster, Steve Cishek and Evan Marshall combined to allow just one walk over their 3⅔ innings, which is one more baserunner than Jose Cisnero and Bryan Garcia allowed over their 2⅔ frames.

Bullet points:

*Collins made his first start behind the plate in 2020. If you didn’t notice the pitchers shaking off signs more than usual, he didn’t stand out, which is good.

*Mazara reached on a double off Mize, but then ran himself into an out at third on a Danny Mendick chopper to the mound.

*Dunning got 17 swinging strikes, Mize 11.

*Look who made it on the broadcast!

Record: 14-11 | Box score | Statcast

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

it seemed quite obvious that dunning shouldn’t have come back after the fourth inning. on the bright side at least none of our announcers brought shame on our organization tonight. thom brennaman is a stupid dickhead. and his dad was a dickhead too. screw them.

LuBob DuRob

I take it they’re on your list?


marty was already on it. i don’t know if thom was but he most certainly is now. i haven’t checked my list in a while.

LuBob DuRob

I had the same feeling of thankfulness for Benetti. Yes, he can get a bit over exuberant with his wit, but he always exudes a joy that is much appreciated right now. I also think he does a good job of creating a sort of ‘family’ feel for the team. Maybe I’m falling victim to all the Zoom debuts this year, but he provides insights into players backgrounds at times that I enjoy.


C. Trent Rosencrans did a fine job of reporting on Brennaman’s slur, his self-defense, and the effects Brennaman’s actions had on Reds fans and players.

John SF

My favorite part of that article is still the inclusion of the Shilling tweet supporting Brennaman at the very end.

It’s more than just damning with faint praise to present him as the notable guy standing up against cance culture.

24 hours later, and it’s even better now that we know Shilling could end up going to jail for the “We Builf the Wall” scam.


Way to go Pnoles! Love the Office reference.

Eagle Bones

Dare I say the best SoxMath intro so far since they started letting the winner cut a video?

As Cirensica

I think Dunning should stay with the team. If he can provide 4 solid innings, that is a plus. Also, I was gladly surprised to see you Patrick on my screen all the sudden. Unexpected, but pretty cool. Kudos.


Collins called a pretty good game last night. I should give him some credit since I always knock him.

Papa Giorgio

Oh man I want a video clip of that Sox math