Getting tangential with 1950s White Sox

We start by bidding farewell to Walt Dropo, then take a wild tour through some unheralded, historic White Sox pitchers.

Walt Dropo, White Sox first baseman from 1955-1958, died Friday night at the age of 87.
Dropo is known mostly for his work before joining the Sox. He broke out in Boston, winning the 1950 Rookie of the Year Award for leading the league with 144 RBI while hitting .322/.378/.583. He never quite matched that production, but he had some good years afterward.
His next stop was Detroit, where he tied a major-league record with 12 consecutive hits in 1952. He’s the only player to do so without a walk.
Dropo’s production tailed off in his last two seasons in Detroit, which allowed Frank Lane to get Dropo for Ferris Fain (an OBP machine with little power) and two minor leaguers.
Lane hoped Dropo would provide the power the 50s Sox sorely lacked. His best days were behind him, but Dropo did lead the 1955 Sox in homers … with 19.
The strange thing about Dropo is that Comiskey Park didn’t kill his power. In fact, he hit way better at the old digs than he did away from it. Adding up his three full seasons:

  • Home: .299/.358/.477
  • Away: .238/.300/.360

Oddly enough, Sherm Lollar also hit better at Comiskey in all three of those seasons, though not with such a great disparity. The same goes for Larry Doby in his big power year of 1956, although he would hit 11 of his 14 homers on the road the following year.
That 1956 is an outlier, though, in that it’s the only time the White Sox 1) had even decent power hitters, and 2) they hit significantly better on the road. I hadn’t realized that their best sluggers didn’t seem to be affected that much.
Anyway, Dropo played first for some pretty good teams — the Sox averaged 89 wins in his three full seasons — before he gave way to Earl Torgeson, and the Sox resumed their habit of having no power at first. Condolences to the Dropo family, especially his grandkids, who sponsor his page.
Farewell also to legendary Chicago Cub Phil Cavarretta, who died on Saturday at the age of 94. For a very, very brief period in 1955, the two players were Chicago’s first basemen. A matter of innings, really.
Speaking of the 1950s, Bill James listed his top 33 rotations of all time (subscriber only). The White Sox are represented four times.
The first two don’t really qualify as big surprises — 1905 and 1920. They’re a year off from their more famous selves, but the 1905 team only needed six pitchers to throw 1,427 innings, and the 1920 rotation featured four 20-game winners, which sets them apart from their pennant-winning brethren.
The last is 1993, which was a very good year. Four of the five starts (Jack McDowell, Alex Fernandez, Wilson Alvarez and Jason Bere) had ERA+ above 120. McDowell won the Cy Young Award, of course, and James identifies him as “one of the last pitchers to stubbornly burn himself out completing games he didn’t need to complete.”
The fourth year is a surprise. I thought 1964 might make it, but I was thinking 10 years too late. James opted for the rotation from 1954, one year before Dropo hit the scene:

Virgil Trucks 19 12 2.79 40 33 16 5 3 264.2 134
Sandy Consuegra 16 3 2.69 39 17 3 2 3 154 139
Bob Keegan 16 9 3.09 31 27 14 2 2 209.2 121
Jack Harshman* 14 8 2.95 35 21 9 4 1 177 127
Billy Pierce* 9 10 3.48 36 26 12 4 3 188.2 107
Don Johnson 8 7 3.13 46 16 3 3 7 144 119

I’ll provide the commentary for this one:

1)  The first team on the list without a Hall of Famer since the Cardinals in ’44.
2)  I think Virgil Trucks is the second pitcher to make our list twice, the other being Christy Mathewson.
3)  This is a really interesting team.   Trucks was a great pitcher with a fascinating career.   Consuegra was a Cuban guy who made it to the majors late and didn’t pitch a lot of innings, but pitched at an extremely high level of effectiveness from 1953 to 1955.
Harshman spent years trying to make the majors as a first baseman.   He hit 37 homers in the minors in 1947, 40 homers in 1949, and 47 homers in 1951, but didn’t get called up.   He switched to pitching, made the majors in months, and had a good major league career, also hit 21 homers in 522 at bats in the majors.   On August 13, 1954, he pitched a 16-inning shutout over Detroit, took one day off, and came in on August 15 to pitch two innings in relief.
Billy Pierce, of course, was a near-Hall of Famer who was outstanding in every season from 1951 to 1958 except 1954.  Pierce also was a member of a rotation that could be listed here but isn’t, the 1962 Giants, and pitched well enough in ’62 to be one of four pitchers mentioned in the Cy Young voting that year.

Trucks and Pierce I knew about — the former because the name “Virgil Trucks” demands you know more about him, and the latter because he’s Billy Pierce.
The stories of Harshman and Consuegra are new to me, which I actually feel slightly ashamed about since they own White Sox records.
Take a look at that box score from Aug. 13, 1954. According to Tom Tango’s basic pitch count estimator, Harshman threw 245 pitches that day. That start earned him the highest game score (109) in White Sox history. When men were men and contracts weren’t guaranteed…
Meanwhile, Consuegra owns the highest winning percentage in White Sox history — at least if you limit it to 15 decisions, which seems like a reasonable number. However, should you want to knock it down a number, the White Sox single-season winning percentage leader is none other than … 1993 Jason Bere!
We started with Walt Dropo, and ended with Jason Bere. That was a lot of fun. At least for me.
Want to know more about Trucks? Of course you do. He’s Virgil Trucks.
A few years ago on The Hardball Times, John Brattain (speaking of late, great people) devoted an entire post to Trucks minutiae. He’s not that far removed from another record:

Trucks was part of a record that will likely never be broken. Washington’s Dean Stone was credited with 1/3 of an inning in the 1954 All-Star Game and got the win. Stone never threw a pitch. With the National League leading 9-8 in the top of the eighth, Stone replaced the White Sox’s Bob Keegan with two out. The Cardinal’s Red Schoendienst took the opportunity to test Stone and tried to steal home. Stone fired to catcher Yogi Berra, and Schoendienst was out to end the inning. The American League plated three runs in the bottom of the eighth to take the lead. Virgil Trucks, replaced Stone in the ninth to finish the game. That left Stone with the win. One win with zero pitches — now that’s a record that may last forever.

Also, Trucks is the uncle to Butch Trucks, the drummer and a founding member of The Allman Brothers Band.
And another thing: All those 1950s names above? They’re all outstanding baseball names.

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
Jim Margalus
Jim Margalus

Writing about the White Sox for a 16th season, first here, then at South Side Sox, and now here again. Let’s talk curling.

Articles: 3715
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Don’t know if you’ve seen this but Jack McDowell’s blog, where he hasn’t posted in over a year, he claims his career was cut short by the famed Dr. James Andrews, not by overuse due to trying to complete games. Here’s the link:
Make sure you read the discussion after this post as it’s pretty interesting.


I think McDowell worked behind the scenes to sue Andrews for a while then when he couldn’t get any doctor to risk their career by testifying against him he finally mentioned it in this blog post. But you think he would make more of it if only to warn other pitchers to be careful.


Yeah reading through the comments, that was the story. It’s very interesting, but I’m skeptical – I’d want to hear the other side of the story. I used to read his blog regularly and I like him, but he seems to place a heavy weight on being “right.” There are couple parts of this story that seem fishy to me. No partial damages, no settlement, just “if you can’t get a doctor to testify, then you got nothing” – combined with a conspiracy that bullied every doctor in the world into refusing to testify? Also, one minute it’s impossible to diagnose, the next minute it’s a super-simple procedure?
Not to say he’s not telling the truth as he sees it or anything, just the old saying “there’s your story, my story, and the truth.”


The 1983 Chicago White Sox had an impressive rotation in 1983, particularly in the second half, when they went on a 44 – 15 tear at one point. It seemed like Bannister, Dotson, and Hoyt won every start after the all-star break, and finished with 16, 22, and 24 victories, respectively. Britt Burns was 10 – 11. I actually still can recall the other guy’s records, too – 16 – 10, 22 – 7, and 24 – 10 – some 27 years later. I was such a baseball stats geek (ahem) back then.
I wonder where James would rank this rotation?


No doubt Burns’ 10 – 11 record played into the rotation not making the cut. Burns was lights out in Game 4 of the ’83 AL Championship Series, save for that heart-breaking HR he suffered that gave Baltimore the series victory. Man, that broke the heart of this then 11-year-old kid.


Might this be the all-time greatest baseball name?
Sloppy Thurston




That’s pretty amazing given his, ahem, stellar 1.8 career SO/9.

Ed Radakovitz

That 1964 team might be the most under rated team in Sox history. They were very good in all aspects but fell just a bit short of the mighty Yankees. Really enjoyed this post. Lots of good stuff here, Well done!


1964 is when I attended my first game at Comiskey. Thanks for the memories, Jim. Great article.


Love this historical piece Jim. I hope you post more similar ones before Spring Training.


Love to see a recap of the ’83 Sox storied second-half run. They were eight games back in May, and yet won the AL West by twenty games. Hoyt, Dotson, and Bannister simply did not lose in the second half.


I’ve been a Sox fan since I became a baseball fan in 1990. I was only 3 in 83 but have loved reading about them. I would also love to see something on the 83 Sox. I think I would have loved watching that team had I been older.




Did anyone else see the “Prime 9” show on Baseball’s greatest rotations? The 2005 White Sox finished fifth or sixth.


I saw that. I’m an MLB Network junky in the offseason. I loved seeing the 2005 Sox right up there.