Trading Craig Kimbrel brings White Sox’s bullpen spending back to Earth

(Matt Marton/USA TODAY Sports)

It would only be appropriate if Craig Kimbrel went on to dominate ninth innings for the Los Angeles Dodgers, because few players were designed to antagonize a White Sox fan base so thoroughly.

He came from the Cubs for a player of worth (Nick Madrigal). He pitched mostly in high-leverage situations. His imitation of a drying rack lost its edge when it mostly served to raise the tension between wild pitches.

Everything about his existence felt fraught, from the intangible to the measurable, including a detectable decrease in velocity. So, when the White Sox picked up his option after an increasingly miserable monthslong debut, it was difficult to imagine the Sox retaining him, because imagine the reaction if he picked up where he left off. Yet it was nearly as hard to envision a robust market for such a player, especially since Kimbrel’s constitution is on the delicate side. Whether or not the ninth inning was a convenient excuse, he still has a history of shaky transitions to new staffs.

The lockout prevented a standard market from forming, and the rush of signings afterward had the urgency of musical chairs, which always leaves somebody on the outside without a seat. Why wouldn’t it be Kimbrel?

Fortunately, we no longer have to entertain that question, because money is no object to the Dodgers, and they have position players to spare. With Kenley Jansen heading to Atlanta, the Dodgers saw a way to fill the Kenley Jansen void with a minimal commitment for somebody who could very well resume being unhittable.

That outcome is a lot easier to ignore since the White Sox received AJ Pollock in return. Pollock’s injury history is checkered enough to lower the ceiling on his expectations, but he should be able to offer something of value, which would feel more satisfying than taking a victory in being done with Kimbrel.

Besides the exchange of talent, the White Sox were able to reduce their spending on relievers to less comical levels. They led the league with a pitcher to spare before the deal

… but while they still hold the edge in portion of payroll devoted to the bullpen, the Dodgers now have them beat in raw dollars.

It also helps that the top six teams in this department are teams worth emulating in at least one way. When the White Sox are among a top tier rather than an echelon of their own, it looks more like a commendable strategy and less like an addiction.

With Kimbrel a Dodger, the biggest question now concerns the extent that Garrett Crochet’s damaged UCL will alter the order of things. He’ll be out for the next year and a half if he undergoes Tommy John surgery as expected, and a team that’s spending $45 million on the bullpen should be able to absorb such a blow, if not two of them. Perhaps Bennett Sousa or another incumbent can fill Crochet’s shoes better than expected, but you’d hope that one of the money guys could buy a rookie time to get adjusted.

Here’s where Joe Kelly could eventually help, because no incumbent White Sox righty besides Liam Hendriks generated special results against lefties, especially after Evan Marshall’s season couldn’t be recovered. Kelly has been equally tough on lefties and righties the last two seasons:

vs. RHP122.178.294.28011.528.7
vs. LHP98.193.255.3078.224.5

But this requires a certain amount of faith that Kelly will fully recover from the nerve injury that ended his postseason and delayed his ramp-up this preseason. When we last heard from Kelly, he and the White Sox were targeting a debut date in late April, so the Sox will have to feel their way around matchups against left-handed hitters for a few weeks regardless.

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
Become a patron at Patreon!
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Joliet Orange Sox

His imitation of a drying rack lost its edge when it mostly served to raise the tension between wild pitches.

So true.


I sure hope Kelly is ready soon. They’re paying him 8.5M for a full season even though he might miss the first few weeks. I don’t understand why they didn’t re-sign Tepera for less, when he would have been ready for opening day and projects to be just as good as Kelly.


It feels like Hahn may have been looking for playoff experience guys with Graveman and Kelly.


Tepera gave up 1 run and 2 baserunners in 4.2 innings with the Sox in the playoffs last year.


Thanks for reminding me how completely crap the pitching was vs the Astros last year. And i agree with you on them bringing Tepera back as he was the only guy that really felt like he was not a fire waiting to happen at the end of the year.


I really think it’s as simple as La Russa liked Kelly from their time together with the Red Sox. So much sway that man holds unfortunately. On the brighter side, I love the Pollock trade.

karkovice squad

A lot of other things will have to go wrong for Joe Kelly’s April availability to be the tipping point for their season.


I did like Tepera’s attitude too.


I’ll just leave this right here:


That looked like a very hittable pitch.

Augusto Barojas

Not making too much of this video, but I still have a feeling this could turn out to be a seriously bad trade for LA. Especially when they could have signed Jansen for exactly what they are paying Kimbrel. We should have a pretty good idea by the end of the month.


This video of Kimbrel on LA makes possibility of April fools joke a lot less likely. For 30 minutes after news I was thinking the trade was a hoax created by mean spirited Cub fan somewhere.

Joliet Orange Sox

Kimbrel gave up 4 earned runs on 4 hits in 1/3 of an inning today raising his spring ERA to 72.00.

To be fair, he was brought in for the 7th inning in a game his team already trailed 4-2. The Dodgers may not be aware that Kimbrel can only pitch in the 9th inning in save situations. I’m sure they’ll figure it out and he’ll pitch well cementing his hall-of-fame credentials.


The comment of the day!


Two things:

  1. It is definitely hilarious that we seem more excited that Kimbrel is gone than AJ Pollock is here. I’m still shocked by this trade a day later.
  2. I am 100% into the idea of one of our minor leaguers being the other lefty out of the pen. Love the Sousa idea, he absolutely deserves a shot.

This is more the kind of deal I expect to see between teams like the Dodgers and BoSox. Exchanging expensive (at least annually) contracts of premier names. White Sox usually don’t find themselves in this position. Feels a bit like being at the high roller table.


Ha totally. Like when a relative gives you a gift certificate to an expensive department store and then you have to go use it.