Gavin Sheets has path to White Sox postseason roster

Jul 19, 2021; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago White Sox first baseman Gavin Sheets (32) celebrates with teammates after hitting a walk-off three run home run against the Minnesota Twins during the seventh inning of a Game 2 of the doubleheader at Guaranteed Rate Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

We don’t yet know how the story of the 2021 White Sox will end, but we do know that it can’t be written without the string of hot weeks from unexpected sources that bridged the gap during the months missed by Eloy Jiménez and Luis Robert. From Yermín Mercedes to Jake Lamb to Brian Goodwin to Adam Engel to Jake Burger to Gavin Sheets, they all plugged the hole at DH for multiple weeks when it appeared the Sox could turn to no one else.

The thing about that sequence is that nobody caught a second wind. Brian Goodwin is the only one who hasn’t disappeared after he arrived, but he’s hitting .222/.317/.340 over his last 50 games. Otherwise, Yermín Mercedes has more retirement announcements (1) than at-bats for the White Sox (0) since they optioned him down in June. Lamb was designated for assignment and claimed by the Blue Jays, with whom he looks like the same guy. Engel returned to the injured list, and Burger suffered a bone bruise that threw him off.

Sheets might be the last chance at lightning striking twice, and his propensity to break out of slumps with big games is what keeps him fascinating. He announced his return to the roster in September with a two-homer game against Pittsburgh. Then, after going 3-for-22 with a walk and seven strikeouts over his next eight games, he pounded the Angels by going 3-for-4 with a majestic three-run homer and four RBIs overall.

Sheets has been able to show immediate improvements in some respects after getting some time to regroup in Charlotte. After going 0-for-12 against left-handed pitching in his first stint, he’s 2-for-3 with a walk this time around. After being held to just one hit on a breaking pitch over his first 100 plate appearances, he’s got two of them in September.

Both of those factors can make him more of a weapon as the White Sox try to determine their best postseason roster. If he could count on getting a 50-percent floor of fastballs, he’d probably be dangerous. But just like Mercedes, Sheets had a hard time putting up a fight once he got to a two-strike count.

Unlike Mercedes, catching up to MLB velocity is not the core issue, so there is room for refinement. James Fegan paints the picture of a guy who is trying to exploit his newfound lifter-puller progress without completely shedding the well-rounded hitting skills that made him an inning-to-inning threat in the minors.

“We’re just trying to stay narrow,” Sheets said, before explaining the consequences of not doing so. “I get out of my legs, and then the balls I’m driving in the air start turning into groundballs or add topspin on long drives. Just trying to stay small and drive the ball.” […]

“I found myself getting to two strikes a lot,” Sheets said. “Whether it was taking pitches or missing my pitch, with getting too big with my swing. So just trying to be ready to go first step when I step in the box, and if I get my pitch, to be able to put a good swing on it.”

With Andrew Vaughn down, Goodwin stagnating and Engel’s legs not worthy of trust, there is a Sheets-shaped opening for serious right field plate appearances. It’s hard to imagine him usurping Goodwin, but he wasn’t a lock to oust Lamb from an expanded roster, so it can’t quite be discarded.

In order to make that happen, he’ll have to limit the slumps in between triumphs. It’s easy to get carried away when Sheets shows off because big left-handed homers never go out of style, but that immediate gratification can only cover so many subsequent 0-fers. Sheets did double on Wednesday night, but he struck out in his other three trips and ran into an out at home, so stringing together successful nights — or at least going 2-for-3 in going 2-for-4 — remains on his to-do list.

Beyond Sheets, second base could have a say in all of this. The White Sox acquired César Hernández assuming he’d be the everyday second baseman, and if he were to eventually resemble that guy, Leury García might be the most obvious play in right field with the way he’s hitting. But if Hernández’s production continues to languish under a .600 OPS while García continues resembling a starter, then it could be an open call in right field after all.

(Photo by Kamil Krzaczynski/USA TODAY Sports)

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
21 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
NorthSideSouthSider

Do we think the Sox will go with 14 position players and 12 pitchers? It seems like they can fit Sheets and Goodwin, if they do that.

Barring injury (and assuming Tepera comes back in time), I think there’s 11 pitchers guaranteed to be on the postseason roster:

Starters: Lynn, Giolito, Rodon, Cease
Bullpen: Lopez, Hendriks, Kimbrel, Kopech, Bummer, Crochet, Tepera

A 12th pitcher would either be Keuchel or a reliever* who I’m not sure they’d want to have out there in a high leverage situation.

*Based on the stats, I think the reliever would probably be Ruiz.

Last edited 2 years ago by Brett R. Bobysud
shaggy65

I’d be very surprised if Ruiz is not on the post-season roster

metasox

If no Vaughn, both of them and more

Last edited 2 years ago by metasox
roke1960

After Tony’s comments this past weekend about Leury, I’m guessing that he will be part of the corner OF/DH trio mix come playoff time. Of course Eloy will be one also, which I think would leave Goodwin and Sheets for the last spot. Both bring plusses/minuses top the table, But I would rather see Sheets than Goodwin at this point.

The big question is what happens against lefties. They need one of Engel/Vaughn to fill that third spot. I wouldn’t trust Sheets or Goodwin against lefties.

dwjm3

I’m not sold on keeping Billy Hamilton. I think a case could made for Keeping Goodwin and Sheets and Launching Hamilton. I’m sure his running and defense are enough for a roster spot.

roke1960

That is very true. I’m just wondering who would get the start in the playoffs, Sheets or Goodwin. There is a very good case for both being on the postseason roster.

mrridgman

Goodwin is descending, Sheets maintaining. I thhought 2 months ago Goodwin was a better defender; now they’re about equal.

Brett R. Bobysud

If Engel’s not healthy, Hamilton will be on the roster as the defensive replacement in the outfield.

Even if Engel is healthy, I could still see Hamilton on the roster.

metasox

If he is healthy, he will be there. After 6 mos together, certain guys are just seen as part of the team chemistry

Last edited 2 years ago by metasox
dwjm3

Tell that to Jake Lamb

metasox

Kinda missing the point

metasox

Could also see Leury at 2B and Hernandez platooning at DH. In that case maybe Romy still around as an infield contingency.

Root Cause

Is Vaughn on the bubble? If so, does that open up a spot? Seems like TLR used him almost every day until he ran out of gas and then got hurt. I would prefer to see a healthy, rested Vaughn in Right rather than Sheets. Put Garcia at 2nd and let Sheets DH.

Last edited 2 years ago by Root Cause
Brett R. Bobysud

If Vaughn’s healthy, I think he’s on the postseason roster.

HallofFrank

He’s on the bubble only because of the injury, but I can’t imagine that he misses the playoffs if healthy. He’s arguably the 2nd best OF defender (somehow!) and he’s got elite offensive talent.

Joliet Orange Sox

I think Robert, Hamilton,and Engel are all clearly better defensive outfielders than Vaughn. That said, I agree a healthy Vaughn is not on the bubble.

HallofFrank

Yes, true, I was thinking at the moment (Engel rehabbing) and forgot that Hamilton was already back.

metasox

Tough time to be out. Guys are getting tuned up for the post-season. Anderson is on the every-other-day-plan, Engel is at least at Charlotte. Vaughn has to come back, play and show he is healthy and effective over at best about 11 games

joewho112

Fangraphs compiled lists of the best and worst bunts of the year. Guess which list Danny Mendick is on

https://blogs.fangraphs.com/the-worst-bunts-of-the-season-so-far/

Trooper Galactus

With old friend Jose Rondon taking the top spot.