Indians 5, White Sox 4 (10 innings): First extra-innings test soggy, underwhelming

Unfortunately, the White Sox got their first taste of extra-inning baseball’s new format for 2020.

Unfortunately, a 46-minute rain delay in the bottom of the 10th means it wasn’t quite a representative experience. And unfortunately, ugly White Sox defense in the top of the 10th means it wasn’t a satisfying experience.

Jimmy Cordero got stuck with the loss as the first White Sox pitcher to inherit a runner on second to start an extra frame, and he did nothing wrong. He started his night by getting a fly to center, and he challenged Carlos Santana and got a dribbler to the left side.

It was well to Yoán Moncada’s left side, and while he gloved it, he bobbled while creating a throwing angle, which meant Cordero had runners on the corners with one out. Delino DeShields Jr. then dropped a good safety squeeze to the right side that revealed Yasmani Grandal’s inexperience at first base.

One of the following was the issue:

  • Since DeShields showed bunt on the previous pitch, Grandal should’ve been charging more aggressively.
  • Since Grandal wasn’t charging aggressively — or because it was a legitimately adequate bunt for a speedy runner on third — he should have gotten the out at first (or yielded to Cordero for that).

Instead, he tried a soft flip to home that was well late, and Cordero still only had one out on the board after recording three outs’ worth of bad contact. A legit single pushed a second run across, and that ended up being the difference.

James McCann was able to get one of the runs back, dropping a single to center as rain drenched the field to make it a 5-4 game. Danny Mendick drew a walk to put the tying run on second. Brad Hand threw one ball to Leury García, then out came the tarp.

When play resumed, Oliver Perez was on the mound, and he got a popout from García and a foul-tip strikeout from Moncada that ended the game.

The loss hurts, not necessarily because the individual game meant so much, but because they were in position to win a Lucas Giolito-Shane Bieber matchup.

The Sox held a 3-2 lead in the bottom of the eighth when Evan Marshall came in to do the job previously held by Aaron Bummer. He retired the first two batters, but he didn’t come at Santana, instead handing him his eighth(!) walk of the series. That came back to bite Marshall when Franmil Reyes doubled Santana home to tie the game.

The game wasn’t all that pretty beforehand, but the Sox offense was powerful enough to overcome its shortcomings.

Bieber recorded 27 swinging strikes on the game, including 10 in an inning. On the other hand, that was the same inning where the White Sox scored two runs to tie the game. McCann hit a no-doubt blast to tie the game, and Grandal doubled home Moncada all the way home from first for the lead.

Giolito didn’t look as dominant as Bieber on the whole, but he finished stronger than his counterpart. He had control problems early, and he had the one inning where the other lineup sat on his changeup and he was slow to adjust, resulting in a two-run third. But he eventually gave him and threw his slider like a preferred second pitch, and to favorable results. He ended up retiring the last seven batters he faced, including three strikeouts in the seventh.

The pitching lines were befitting of a Sunday Night Baseball matchup:

  • Giolito: 7 IP, 4 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 5 BB, 9 K
  • Bieber: 6 IP, 4 H, 3 R, 3 ER, 2 BB, 8 K

Bullet points:

*Abreu started the scoring with a solo shot in the second inning. After going 0-for-14 in the first inning over the first 15 games, Abreu finally found a way to pounce early.

*McCann delivered two big hits, but he put Alex Colomé in a bind with his second catcher interference of the season that put two on with two outs in the ninth. Colomé pitched around it.

*The White Sox struck out 16 times, including two apiece from the top six hitters in the lineup.

Record: 8-8 | Box score | Statcast

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
Become a patron at Patreon!
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

If it hadn’t already been raining pretty hard at the time, I think that Luis Robert fly ball in the 10th had a chance to go.

I’m encouraged to see Abreu moved down to the 4th position in the lineup–that’s really the perfect spot for him. I wouldn’t mind seeing Grandal batting 3rd except that he and Moncada are very similar hitters. I know he’s in a slump right now, but I’d love to see Jimenez batting 3rd. Or hell, even McCann–who’s been on fire! Keep EE on the bench “recovering” for now because James has looked head and shoulders better.

My ideal lineup once Timmy’s back:
1. Anderson
2. Moncada
3. Jimenez
4. Abreu
5. Grandal
6. McCann
7. Mazara
8. Robert
9. Garcia/Mendick


Yep, that Robert ball would have at least required a leaping grab at the wall. Tough break.

I like your lineup, although I would move Robert to 4th and move Abreu down to 6th.


That’s a really bad series/game loss, could be one you look back at if things are tight for a playoff spot and kick yourself for. Give the sox credit for fighting with an arm tied behind their backs as the injuries have been ridiculous to this point but that was one they really needed to get.

So Arod showed up like 3 minutes before game time and someone gave him a bad cliff notes version of all things whitesox, right? Lets see Roger Bozart the groundskeeper, the stadium only being a hitters park for the last 7 or 8 years, no clue that EE was unavailable for a pinch hitting role as he brought him up countless times as a possible weapon on the bench, declared Giolito a two pitch fb, slider pitcher before correcting himself and calling him a fastball change up pitcher.

Can anyone explain why on the flip to mendick for the force out at 2nd base that was reviewed, a possible interference play wasnt called that would of resulted in a double play?????


Thanks for this Jim. This was driving me nuts yesterday not knowing why they weren’t even discussing it


Yes, ARod was awful. He kept saying “the center-fielder” or “the second basemen” because he clearly had no idea who they were. If nothing else, it maybe me especially thankful for Benetti and Stone.


To be fair, it wasn’t a Yankees & BoSox game so they were out of their element


I would love to see the called strikes for this. It was painful to watch Robert strike out when he should’ve never been in a 2 strike count to begin with. There was also the awful called third strike on Grandal but we got one back in the next inning with a terrible call low. It seemed like the strike zone was solid in the early going and then it slowly grew more and more inconsistent as the game went on and my bias is saying that inconsistency favored the Indians but I would like to see the actual results.


This is the first game I really thought we got the short end of the zones, sox hitters seemed like they had an extra inch on each side of the plate to cover and indians hitters the opposite.


An argument could be made that Bieber earned a wider zone compared to Gio but it felt like the zone was tight and fair in the first half of the game and then it opened up for the Sox as the game progressed. It might have been the same for the Indians and I just didn’t notice because we weren’t missing as close as they were. I’m just wondering if there was a conscious effort on the Ump’s part to speed up the game because of the storm cell coming in, if it was just bad misses, or if its just confirmation bias on our part.