Sox can learn by bad examples

Jim Leyland is no stranger to overmanaging.
I thought he’d set the gold standard last year when he intentionally walked A.J. Pierzynski twice
…and the second one came in the eighth inning, two outs and the Tigers trailing by seven.
The Sox rubbed Leyland’s face in it. Carlos Quentin cleared the bases with a triple, Joe Crede singled and Juan Uribe doubled before Yorman Bazardo (anagram: “Boozy Radar Man”) finally got the third out.
Nope, he topped it on Saturday night, and possibly the worst. He called for the intentional walk four times (the 41st time it’s happened in an AL game since 1954; basically one a year), and Alfredo Figaro basically issued a non-intentional IBB to Brent Lillibridge to load the bases in the second.
Unfortunately, the Sox never really made it hurt.  At least they scored a run when Leyland called for a LOOGY in the second inning.
I can’t tell you off-hand how rare that move is, but I did go through Play Index and find that no American League manager called for a LOOGY to face one batter in the first half of the game. It happened twice in the NL, and both came in the fourth inning.
Leyland’s Game 161 strategy might rival Bob Brenly’s World Series Game 5 as the worst big-game managerial performance in recent memory. That LOOGY call seemed to fill Comerica Park with dread before Placido Polanco failed to handle Scott Podsednik’s hot shot cleanly. He got one out instead of two, a run crossed the plate, and the White Sox had their insurmountable 2-0 lead with 22 outs left to go.
Ozzie Guillen hasn’t had the best of seasons, but he’s never turned coal into diamonds over the course of two innings the way Leyland did tonight. Hopefully he stored that away for the next time he has a big game. Hopefully, that’ll be as soon as next season.
And hopefully the Sox learned something from Saturday night, because they were basically playing themselves. We watched such familiar elements as:
*Tiger hitters watching hittable pitches and swinging at junk thrown by a pitcher who, by most accounts, shouldn’t experience big-league success on a routine basis.
*Tiger hitters having runners on the corners, nobody out, and coming away with nothing.
*Tiger outfielders giving away outs with terrible judgment.
Meanwhile, the Sox stole six bases in six attempts, played first-to-third ball and dropped in a number of big bloop hits.
Maybe it was the full moon, or maybe this is what happens when a manager prepares for the worst with his decision-making.
A couple other thoughts:
*Alex Rios had the softest three hits in one game since Pablo Ozuna in 2006, but they all count.  And honestly, with the amount of medium-range flyouts the Sox hit, a guy who can hit bloop singles is welcome.
On the other hand, he let another ball drop right in front of him in right field — Curtis Granderson’s single that led to the Tigers’ first — and as we’d come to find out, only — run. Throw that in with the back-breaking Nick Punto single on Sept. 23, and I’m starting to wonder if I’ve ever actually seen him leave his feet.
*Carlos Quentin, on the other hand, stung the ball three times, and was stung by the ball twice.  A 428-foot homer, a  flyout to center that would’ve been a homer at the Cell, a roped double, a pitch off the triceps and one off the bill of the helmet is just about the ultimate CQ game.
And it’s games like an ultimate CQ game that lead me to believe that Quentin’s health will be the single biggest variable for the 2010 White Sox. Outside of Barry Bonds, one player isn’t responsible for turning a 79-win team into one that wins 90-plus games, but at the same time, if Quentin could be counted upon, Kenny Williams’ job would be so much easier over the coming months.

Take a second to support Sox Machine on Patreon
Become a patron at Patreon!
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I agree with absolutely everything you said about leyland (especially the intentional walks) except the move to use the loogy. He had galaraga up and ready to come in for long relief but why not use your situational lefty in probably the most crucial time that may come up in the game if your pulling the starter anyway. The inning shouldnt really matter, Leyland knew the tigers werent gonna score much and heck pods hit a perfect double play ball that polanco booted.
Rios’s bloop parade was impressive, but yea I was surprised he didnt get to that ball in right as well.
Quentin is a huge wild card, he has started to swing that bat, and even hawk and stoney alluded to him being the 3 hitter again next year when he comes back healthy.


I didn’t get to see or listen to the game last night, but ran into a bunch of people talking about the last couple important series this weekend. Was asked several tomes who I wanted to win between Twins and Tigers, I responded “I hate Leyland.”
Thanks Jim, I can now send them this to help my case.
However, I’m sure the national sports media is still singing his praises as some kind of revolutionary, funny looking old gent.


If the White Sox and the Bears win today, and if the Blackhawks beat the Red Wings tomorrow, will Detroit ask for another stimulus package?


The Blackhawks play Detroit Thursday.


I’d still rather see the Tigers go to the postseason over the twinkies. No idea why.