theories

...now browsing by tag

 
 

Jose Contreras: Fall guy

Tuesday, August 25th, 2009

Barack Obama took the week off from the health care debate to vacation with the First Family on Martha’s Vineyard, so it’s entirely possible that he got to watch Ozzie Guillen pull the plug on grandpa.

Guillen, the one-man death panel, sent Jose Contreras to the bullpen after his catastrophic outing on Monday night.  Words can’t adequately describe the horror of witnessing that error unfold. It was like watching a baby crawl towards a cliff.  There was no immediate sense of danger, but it developed so slowly that you still had time to fully realize that, hey, maybe that infant doesn’t have the ability to judge depth.

Is this what we'll remember Jose Contreras by? (AP)

Is this what we'll remember Jose Contreras by? (AP)

Now, replace “that infant” with “Jose Contreras ” and “judge depth” with “field his position, even to the level of Clayton Richard,” and there you go.

It’s a new take on an old Mitch Hedberg joke: “I want to see a pitcher flop during a flop. It would be so damn literal!”

So Contreras heads to the bullpen, which is a vanity assignment for all intents and purposes. He won’t be available until Aug. 29, and rosters expand three days later, so Guillen is basically saying, “We hope we’ll never need you.”

That leaves the door open for Jake Peavy, who pitched well enough in his third rehab start but took a liner to his pitching elbow in the process. He was fine enough to finish, but he has to see how it feels in the coming days.

It also closes the door on the chance of Contreras returning for 2010, in all likelihood. That is, if you hadn’t already ruled it out by now.

When piecing together the 2010 roster in my head, I had the Count penciled in (very, very lightly) as the fifth starter at Bartolo Colon’s salary. They would receive all the benefits of Contreras, Cuban Idol at a fraction of the price, there were reasons to expect mild improvement, and since he couldn’t be counted upon to pitch a full season, he wouldn’t interfere with the progress of Daniel Hudson or anybody else who might be ready to make The Leap.

But it’s hard to treat Monday’s debacle like anything besides a watershed moment in his White Sox career. It feels too much like it did last year, when Javier Vazquez followed up a Guillen challenge (“I don’t have an ace here”) by immediately surrendering a lead in the September Metrodome series. Maybe it was 100 percent certain Vazquez would be dealt, but it was impossible to imagine how anybody — Vazquez, Guillen, fans, the media — would’ve dealt with it after Guillen branded him with the scarlet “U.”

If Guillen removed Contreras from the rotation after a run-of-the-mill shelling, I don’t think that would’ve cemented his fate in the same way. But now when I think of Contreras, I’ll picture him diving in desperation for the ball like an alcoholic trying to suck spilled beer out of carpet fibers. That image is burned in the collective memory, and it’s hard to see anybody overlooking it.

Click to continue »

Bloody Sundays

Monday, August 24th, 2009

If the Sox have been consistent at anything this year, they’ve been great at keeping the Sabbath Day holy.

The rubber match loss to Baltimore (the worst team in the league) and Jason Berken (the guy with the 2-11 record) means the Sox have now lost on seven of the last eight Sundays.

The annual Mark Buehrle "It's August and I stink" photo. (AP)

The annual Mark Buehrle "It's August and I stink" photo. (AP)

Although it feels like Ozzie Guillen has always held that day of the week in lower (or higher) esteem, that may be more of a lingering sentiment from the Jerry Manuel era.  Here are the Sunday records for each season since Guillen took over:

  • 2009: 7-13
  • 2008: 17-10
  • 2007: 8-18
  • 2006: 14-13
  • 2005: 14-11
  • 2004: 16-10

It’s funny that 2007 is the only other Guillen season in which the Sox have sported a losing record on Sundays, because even though the Sox are still two games over .500, this year feels a whole lot closer to that wreck than any kind of championship campaign.

It makes sense. Sunday has been the day things get thwarted. Sweep? Thwart. Series win? Thwart. A winning streak? Thwart. Add in the day off afterward (there have been three Mondays off in July and August), and that’s just another 24 hours to stew about those particular missed opportunities.

Maybe Guillen should plan his week like newspapers do.  The biggest circulation days for newspapers are Thursday and Sunday. Those are the most advertiser-friendly days of the week, and so it also becomes the biggest day for a newsroom.  They want to save their best work for when the most people will see it.

Likewise, Sundays and Thursday might be best regarded as All Starters’ Day. Guillen shalt not play backup catchers, fifth outfielders or utility infielders when there’s anything resembling momentum on the line. Maybe it might not make a difference in the standings, playing the bench players on Mondays or Fridays, but it would certainly make an impact on the emotional aspect.

Then again, the Sox are 16-4 on Saturdays this season. If momentum were that reliable, you’d think that would spill over to the following day more often than it does.

Click to continue »