Sunday, March 16, 2008 - Posts

No winners in this trade

Has there been a White Sox trade in recent history that worked out as poorly for everybody involved as the Neal Cotts-David Aardsma deal?

Cotts not only gave up the game-winning homer to Jim Thome today, but the blast managed to leave Tucson Electric Park's premises -- and Thome can't hit lefties, as we know.  This came just three days after the Sox handed Carlos Vasquez, the third member of that ill-fated trade, his walking papers.

After today, Cotts has surrendered eight runs on eight hits and five walks in six innings.  Some were surprised Cotts was even tendered a contract, and he's not doing anything to remove doubts.  On the other end, Vasquez walked six in four innings before his release Wednesday, and Aardsma was traded for two A-ball relievers in January.

Looking back through the transactions, you probably have to go all the way back to the David Wells-Mike Sirotka trade in January 2001 to find an exchange of major-league players that ultimately didn't help either team one bit.  Wells contributed a little more than Aardsma, but his mouth and work ethic negated most of his contributions.

Over in Red Sox camp, Aardsma is seeing mixed results this spring -- nine strikeouts in 6 2/3 innings, yet two homers as well -- but he looks like late-90s Mariano Rivera by comparison.

**********************

Other observations from today's game:

*Joe Crede nearly dropped below the Karkovice Line (.071) entering his third at-bat, but Cotts gave him a boost by allowing a first-pitch double off the top of the left-center wall.  More importantly, he scored on a shallow sacrifice fly by Alexei Ramirez, sliding around an attempted tag by Geovany Soto by going around him and reaching with his hand.  If his back wasn't healthy, I don't know if he'd be able to do that.

*Ramirez's sac fly came on -- you guessed it -- a first-pitch fastball.

*Nick Masset was around 90-92 m.p.h. all day long.  Even if he was conserving some energy because he was starting, it's clear that the Sox overestimated the power of his right arm.  They're still not understimating his abilities though, because he's pretty much a lock for the bullpen.

The Bourgeois uprising

After the Sox released Carlos Vasquez Wednesday, it opened a spot on the previously full 40-man roster.  It will likely remain vacant until after any potential trades (Joe Crede, et al) are hammered out, but Jason Bourgeois could very well stake his claim if nobody else fills it.

Bourgeois had another big day at the plate from the leadoff spot, reaching base three times (one single, two walks) and stealing three bases in today's 5-3 victory over the Cubs in Tucson.

On top of that, he also did the little things.  With Juan Uribe on second base, he shot an RBI single through the right side.  He advanced to second on Kosuke Fukudome's throw home, and then took another bag on Orlando Cabrera's flyout to left, taking advantage of Matt Murton's poor position on the catch.  He did miss one opportunity, popping out with runners on second and third and nobody out, but the positives outweighed the negatives.

During the broadcast, Kenny Williams joined Hawk Harrelson and Darrin Jackson in the booth and noted that Bourgeois was a six-year minor-league free agent and had the option of signing anywhere else in the offseason, but chose to remain with the White Sox.  The key points:

KW: "I said [to Bourgeois' agent, Dave Stewart], we like him, we said we believe he could ultimately serve a purpose in a utility role with us if something happens at the big-league level ... He's done nothing but impress.  First of all, I'm impressed that he made the decision to come back -- a lot of guys wouldn't do that.  They both had faith in us that we would live up to our word and give him an opportunity.    He's now put himself in the mix if something happens to, let's say, an Ozuna -- he's that type of player where he can come in and give you some energy off the bench at various positions. [...]

Hawk: Well, to me, just watching him this spring, he's first man up if somebody goes down.

KW:  Well, I couldn't argue with that as we sit here today.

After today's game, Bourgeois is hitting .353/.463/.441 with three doubles and a 2:1 walk strikeout ratio.  Not to rain on his parade, but there are a couple reasons to qualify the excitement:

No. 1:  Of his six walks, three have been on four pitches. 

Last year, Bourgeois walked 45 times over 574 plate appearances over his stints in Birmingham and Charlotte.  That's acceptable for a guy who's not a home-run threat, but it's a little worse than Jerry Owens' walk rate in the minors.  Owens has walked about half as often in the big leagues, so nobody should expect Bourgeois to reach base nearly as easily as he's doing now.

No. 2:  As far as I know, he's not a defensive whiz anywhere.

Bourgeois hasn't looked Rob Mackowiak Bad™ in center, but his lack of experience has shown at times.  In today's game, he appeared to underestimate the stiff breeze to right field and let a high fly get past him in right center, and the wind also turned him around in the first week of spring.

I've only seen him play second once --  that night, he couldn't glove a soft grounder, and the error led to three runs.  In his defense, that was at Alliance Bank Stadium in Syracuse and its awful artificial turf.  The plastic grass is no more, as they've replaced it with the real stuff for next season.

Still, although I offer some caveats, it's hard to knock anything Bourgeois has done in the past calendar year.  He hit and ran in Birmingham, hit and ran even better in Charlotte, and now he's hitting and running his best in Tucson as we speak. 

Since the Sox don't have to give him a roster spot, Williams will likely take advantage of his flexibility and wait until all other personnel moves have been addressed.  But I'd wager to guess that before the All-Star break, Williams will reward Bourgeois for his loyalty. 

Of course, stealing second and third in succession and with ease in front of Williams, who was in the broadcast booth during the sixth inning, might help accelerate the process a little.