posted on Friday, June 13, 2008 2:51 AM by Jim

Extolling the virtues of the six-man bullpen

Per Scott Merkin, Esteban Loaiza's second stint with the White Sox is coming to a close after nine whole days and several sub-80 m.p.h. fastballs thrown.

Taking his place?  Adam Russell.  And it irks me.  Boy, does this irk me.

It's not because Russell's a bad pitcher.  Nobody can say that for sure.  He's done a nice job limiting hits in Charlotte (20 in 31 innings) and runs (1.74 ERA), although his walk-to-strikeout rate is worrisome (15 BB, 24 K).

It's because he'll probably be of more use as the tallest guy on the team than he will as somebody who could potentially help the Sox win ballgames.  And at 6'6", Matt Thornton can probably handle the tall guy duties just as well, duties which mostly consist of hiding sandwiches above the ceiling tiles in the locker room.

The timing of this move highlights precisely what is flawed with the decision-making, as it comes on the heels of a day in which Mark Buehrle threw eight innings for the second consecutive start, and the Sox could only manage five hits off Detroit pitching.

Ozzie Guillen used only Octavio Dotel, and Dotel threw only one-third of an inning.   That one out will be enough to give the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim the title of "fewest innings thrown by a bullpen," since they had an off day and they and the Sox were tied at 173 innings apiece.  But when considering Sox relievers have allowed 37 fewer hits, they have the "fewest batters faced" title won handily at this point.

Also, Nick Masset has appeared in one more game than Buehrle, so it's clear that Ozzie Guillen has had enough trouble finding work for his worst reliever as it is.

Meanwhile, Sox hitters have only scored 10 runs in their last six road games, and outside of the perfect homestand, haven't been a lock to score runs on a consistent basis at home, either.  So what exactly Adam Russell is going to bring to this team except the ability to post up Thornton in pickup hoops games and play janitor in the increasingly rare mop-up opportunities is beyond me.

That's why it seems to me that the time is right to call up Josh Fields.  Three reasons:

No. 1:  The schedule.  The Sox have the next two Mondays off.  If they were able to survive 15 innings against the Royals with no off days in sight for the next week and a half afterward, it seems like they should be OK with this stretch.  The Cubs will surely test Sox pitching, but in between the crosstown series, the Sox will face the Rockies, Pirates and Dodgers -- all of whom are in the bottom half of baseball in terms of OPS.

No. 2:  There are enough at-bats.  Fields is an automatic platoon partner for Jim Thome, and even Joe Crede.  Crede's single off Kenny Rogers Thursday was only his fifth hit off left-handed pitching over 46 at-bats.  At least he's now batting over .100 against southpaws.

No. 3:  What's the harm?  If Fields comes up and doesn't hit over the next two weeks, the Sox can send him back down and bring up another reliever when the off days disappear after the All-Star break.  If he does hit, Ozzie Guillen suddenly has a lot more flexibility in making lineups.

Fields' current numbers aren't all that impressive, as he's down 35 points on his batting average and 50 points on his OBP compared to his Charlotte numbers last year, but he's the best shot the Sox have at instant improvement offensively.  He certainly stands a much better chance of getting the Sox back on track over a pitcher whose sole purpose will be to pitch in games he can't affect.

**********************

Minor league roundup:
  • Charlotte 3, Norfolk 2
    • Clayton Richard had a successful Triple-A debut, allowing two runs on five hits over seven innings, with no walks and five strikeouts.
    • Ehren Wassermann worked two innings for his save, striking out four to one hit and one walk.
    • Jerry Owens went 3-for-5 with a run scored, though he was caught stealing.  He is hitting .395 in June.
    • Danny Richar went 1-for-4 with his fifth steal, first unsuccessful attempt and sixth error.
    • Jason Bourgeois went 2-for-3 with his sixth stolen base; Paul Phillips also had two hits.
  • Carolina 3, Birmingham 2
    • Justin Cassell allowed two runs over six innings, scattering nine hits, walking nobody and striking out five.
    • Brian Omogrosso took the loss with one run allowed over 2 2/3 innings.
    • Javier Castillo collected a pair of doubles; Victor Mercedes went 2-for-4.
  • Winston-Salem 1, Wilmington 0
    • John Ely allowed one hit over seven innings, retiring 21 of the 22 batters he faced including the last nineteen, striking out eight (including five of the last nine).
    • Kanekoa Teixeira worked two innings for his 11th save.
    • Adam Ricks' solo homer provided the game's only run, and he had a single as well.
  • Lexington 2, Kannapolis 1
    • Santo Luis struck out nine over five innings, allowing one unearned run on two hits and no walks.
    • Logan Johnson went 2-for-4, including a double.

Comments

# re: Extolling the virtues of the six-man bullpen

Friday, June 13, 2008 11:40 AM by soxfan1
Great points Jim, especially the fact that the Sox are tied for the fewest bullpen innings thrown. Since we are coming into the interleague portion of the schedule more flexibilty among position players would be really helpful! Why not give Fields a call? He has been a good soldier all year and is starting to hit at Charlotte. Our hitting has been poor to pathetic all year except for our two 7-8 game winning streaks. When we get away from the Cell, it's like watching a horror show at the plate (remember Minn, Toronto, Tampa & now Detroit). I don't like seeing Konerko, Thome & Dye in a row at any time. Fields would be a welcome replacement!!

# re: Extolling the virtues of the six-man bullpen

Friday, June 13, 2008 11:49 AM by Joist
Jim,

You're spot on with this one. The only reason I can think of why they are doing this is to cover their asses. If their starting pitching suddenly hits a rough spot and they only have six relievers, they get blasted for doing something unconventional that led to a problem. Of course, that doesn't answer the obvious question, which is that they can just wait to call up a reliever until they need one. What they need now is a frigging bat -- did Ozzie already forget what he was ranting about just ten days ago?

# re: Extolling the virtues of the six-man bullpen

Friday, June 13, 2008 4:11 PM by soxexile
I basically agree with Jim, but possibly they want to keep Fields in Charlotte so he gets more AB's, and can improve more than he's likely to do on the bench in Chicago. Granted, that doesn't do anything for us immediately.

# re: Extolling the virtues of the six-man bullpen

Friday, June 13, 2008 4:41 PM by Jim Margalus
Between Thome struggling, Konerko's hand hurting and Crede's inability to hit lefties, I think he could at least play every other day.

It's just frustrating, because they're handicapping themselves by not using the best facet of their team to their advantage.

# re: Extolling the virtues of the six-man bullpen

Saturday, June 14, 2008 10:25 AM by soxfan1
If not Fields, how about Brad Eldred?? 22 hr's in less than half of a year should not be totally discounted!

# re: Extolling the virtues of the six-man bullpen

Sunday, June 15, 2008 5:26 AM by Jim Margalus
It shouldn't, but he's another all-or-nothing type player in a lineup that's full of them.